Some things should stay buried, like old flames, and dead bodies. Former golden boy Andrew eases his anxiety by working at the museum, preserving the past while trying to forget his own. But when the town's favorite celebrity comes home Andrew's hard-won peace could be shattered along with his heart. Josh brings life to other people's fears and buries his own. But when he returns home he resurrects his own worst nightmare. Reunited, these old friends have a chance to finally become lovers, but regrets older than their own may tear them apart.