Jessica McLean opens shop to find a man has been left for dead on the floor of her diner. With very few clues left behind, Jessica becomes the prime suspect. But Amish twin sisters and amateur sleuths, Beth and Anna, wonder if the crime could be related to Jessica's new relationship with their beloved Matthew Beiler. It soon becomes clear that things aren't always as they seem.Will the sisters step in and solve the mystery, bringing justice to Little Valley yet again?