Captain Evans and his crew have been on the up and up. Until one night when something happens to change their plans. Now back being their cutthroat pirate selves, they begin an adventure that changes them forever. Captain Evans finds himself falling in love with a beautiful, spirited young woman and her three brothers. The more he fights, the more that he finds himself closer to her. Will he give in to his feelings or walk away from them? Will he and his crew be able to turn back to stay on the up and up or will they stay pirates once again?