Best-selling author, Paige Lockheart, is divorced and lives alone with her cat Drusilla. With only a few weeks till Christmas, the local school library burns down, so her closest friend Bryan, the school teacher, devises a plan to record a Christmas song in order to fund more books. With Paige's writing talent and his singing voice, they produce a Christmas classic. But the past comes calling twice for Paige, an ex-husband and a prior love. Who will she choose on Christmas Eve?