An overnight stay at Aaron and Jeff's comes with an unexpected surprise. Serena needs a place to stay while the heat in her apartment is fixed, and her best friend Aaron is quick to offer his guest room. Sure, she's fantasized about her bisexual best friend, but him having a live-in boyfriend makes him... gay... right? That night, Serena receives an eyeful when the two men leave their bedroom door open. The following morning, the two men confront her with one question: Why didn't she join them last night?