"The tooth fairy's been arrested." Those words startled Liz Farley awake on a Saturday morning. Being a lawyer to the fae, she heads to the Louisville police station, only to come face to face with the one man she can never really forget. Colm swears to her he's innocent, but with his history of skirting the edges of truth, can she really believe him? Colm is sick and tired of the merry-go-round of empty headed women he's dated for decades, and has decided to convince his off-again, on-again lover, that they really do belong together. But then, while he's out doing a favor for his sister, he finds himself being accused of a theft he didn't commit. Can she give up her strict black and white view of the law, and the world, to let him back into her life? And her heart?